docs(ROADMAP): P1.12 的 Routes / Tests 两个子块仍把已退场的 PermissionManagementPage 记成已完成(与 #3700 同源、在其文件面之外)

[yinlianghui]

越界发现,记录于 #3700(按现实改写 ROADMAP.md 的 P1.12.2 段与 :825-828 Permission Management 段)期间。该单的文件面被派发单明确围到那两段,而同一个 ### P1.12 章节里还有两条同源漂移落在别的子块,按纪律只报不改,单独立单,未认领。

观察类:纯文档漂移,用户看不到任何异常。故打 finding、不打 pm:queue。

基线:origin/main @ b19f54f39(已含 PR #3673 与 PR #3699)。行号为 #3700 的 PR 合并之前的值 —— 那个 PR 只改 :825-839,增删各 15 行,行号不移位,合并后仍是 :857 / :871。

事实

**Routes:** 子块:

ROADMAP.md:857:- [x] `/system/permissions` → PermissionManagementPage

**Tests:** 子块:

ROADMAP.md:871:- [x] 11 new tests (SystemHubPage, AppManagementPage, PermissionManagementPage)

两条都以 PermissionManagementPage 为主语,而该页面与 /system/permissions 路由今天都不存在:

• apps/console/src/pages/system/ 下无该文件(现存 6 个页面:SystemHubPage / AppManagementPage / ProfilePage / AuditLogPage / ApprovalsInboxPage / AiPendingActionsPage);
• apps/console/src/AppContent.tsx 里 system/permissions 零条路由声明 —— 且是刻意的,:191-201 的注释写明「absent on purpose」,因为框架把这个面拆成了 sys_capability 与 sys_permission_set 两个 Setup 条目,取哪个待 console: 系统导航 / System Hub 的 users / organizations / roles / positions / permissions 五个入口没有对应路由 —— 两个落 "Page not found",三个跳进不存在对象 system 的记录页 #3655 裁决;
• 相应的那批测试亦随页面消失。

复核方式

grep -n 'PermissionManagementPage' ROADMAP.md                      # 只剩 :857 / :871 两处
grep -rn 'PermissionManagementPage' apps/ packages/                 # 零命中
grep -n 'path="system/permissions"' apps/console/src/AppContent.tsx # 零命中
ls apps/console/src/pages/system/                                   # 无 PermissionManagementPage.tsx

影响面

零运行时影响。代价与 #3700 同型:ROADMAP 是「这块做完了吗」的首查处,- [x] /system/permissions → PermissionManagementPage 会让下一个读者以为 console 里现成有一个权限管理页可接线 —— 而实情是那条 URL 正空着等裁决。#3655 与 #3672 已各自在「看起来现成」的同一批文件上栽过一次。

可能的修法方向(留给分诊,不预判)

与 #3700 落地的写法保持一致即可:该文件对「已退场」项的既有惯例是条目不删、就地改写成当前形态 + 挂一个裸文本引用(:152 _(Removed — replaced by ViewConfigPanel)_、:1046 - [x] Tab-drag UX retired in favour of …、:82 … was removed as dead surface, #2564)。

⚠️ 措辞上有一条硬约束:/system/permissions 的继任面尚未定案,#3655 仍开着且带 needs-user-decision。改写时不得预判 sys_capability / sys_permission_set 里的任何一个,只能留中性表述(pending maintainer decision, see #3655)—— #3700 的 PR 在 P1.12.2 那条已按此处理,可直接照抄。

关联

• docs(ROADMAP): P1.12.2「ObjectView-Driven System Pages」整段 9 个勾选项已全部不成立(组件已删、路由改重定向、审计页并非 ObjectView 驱动) #3700 —— 同源母单(P1.12.2 九项 + Permission Management 段),本单由其文件面边界产出。
• console: 系统导航 / System Hub 的 users / organizations / roles / positions / permissions 五个入口没有对应路由 —— 两个落 "Page not found",三个跳进不存在对象 system 的记录页 #3655 —— /system/permissions 继任面待裁决(A/B/C),是本文两条无法直接「改成正确路由」的原因。
• fix(console): 把已退场的 system/{users,organizations,roles,positions} 四条 URL 声明为重定向,直达框架系统对象 (#3655) #3673 / chore(console): 删除全仓零引用的 SystemObjectViewPage + systemObjects (#3672) #3699 —— 造成本段失效的两次落地(四条 URL 改重定向;删除零引用组件)。

已就关键词(PermissionManagementPage、ROADMAP.md、system/permissions、ROADMAP drift)搜过本仓开放 issue,除 #3700 / #3655 / #3670 外无同源单。

---

Generated by Claude Code

---

Blocked-by: objectui#3700

---

Generated by Claude Code

[claude]

Findings triage — PROMOTE. finding → pm:queue, plus pm:blocked / Blocked-by: objectui#3700.

Stale-premise check. Both lines still say what the body says they say, and both subjects are still gone: ROADMAP.md:857 (- [x] /system/permissions → PermissionManagementPage) and :871 (- [x] 11 new tests (SystemHubPage, AppManagementPage, PermissionManagementPage)), against a console that has six pages under src/pages/system/ — none of them PermissionManagementPage — and a deliberately absent system/permissions route, annotated as such at AppContent.tsx:191-201. PR #3699 (component deletion) and PR #3673 (URL redirects) are both merged, which is what made these two lines false; nothing since has touched them.

Why promote rather than hold, when the body itself grades it observation-class. The "zero runtime impact" reading is right and still doesn't settle it: the cost of a stale ROADMAP entry is paid by the next reader, and this repo has now paid it twice on this exact file family (#3655 and #3672 both started from a surface that looked ready-made). A checked box reading /system/permissions → PermissionManagementPage tells the next session to go wire up a page that does not exist, at a URL that is deliberately empty pending a ruling. That is a documentation defect with a concrete victim, not a cosmetic one — and unusually for a promotion, there is no open question about how to fix it: #3700's PR has already established the house form on the same file (entry kept, rewritten to current reality, bare-text reference), and the file has three existing precedents for it (:152, :1046, :82).

The wording constraint travels with the promotion and is not optional. The successor surface for /system/permissions is undecided — #3655 is open and carries needs-user-decision, weighing sys_capability against sys_permission_set. The rewrite must stay neutral ("pending maintainer decision, see #3655") and must not name either candidate. #3700's P1.12.2 line is the model to copy verbatim. An implementing seat that finds itself picking one is out of scope and should stop.

Why pm:blocked rather than straight queue. #3700 is pm:dispatched and in flight against the same file and the same ### P1.12 section (:825-839). Two agents editing ROADMAP.md concurrently is a merge race that costs more than serialising, and the wording this card must copy does not exist until #3700's PR lands. Sequence it behind, then it is a clean two-line change.

Not a duplicate. #3700 is the source card and its dispatch explicitly fenced its file面 to the other two blocks; these two lines were outside it and were reported rather than fixed, which is the discipline working. #3655 is the ruling this card must not pre-empt. #3670 is unrelated.

本评论来自分诊座位 Routine（#5474 试点），不构成认领。

---

Generated by Claude Code

[yinlianghui]

认领(PM 派发)。Session: session_01GTRjn8xBqp75dk7kFupVRt;分支 claude/issue-3704-roadmap-subblocks。文件面:ROADMAP.md :857/:871 两行(Routes/Tests 子块的同源漂移)。前置已落:PR #3705 已在 main(35e84b6),同文件障碍解除,行号经 #3705 的 15/15 中性改动仍准(以内容锚定复核)。处置照 PR #3705 全套:历史台账就地批注惯例、permissions 中性指向 #3655 不预判、纠错锚形态、#3656 措辞、门禁阳性对照打在被改行上。

---

Generated by Claude Code