You signed in with another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You signed out in another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You switched accounts on another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.Dismiss alert
I have a general query regarding react vs solid implementations. I see there is quite a lot missing from the solidjs port (and well the other libs vs react).
Please don't take this as any form of criticism. I'm bringing this up as I am genuinely interested if there are any technical limitations on why the solidjs port is lagging so far behind React, as skin deep they are mostly the same (i.e essentially being javascript and useState, useEffect vs createSignal, createEffect) and it shouldn't be too difficult to keep them in sync. Although from experience, I know that some patterns for react don't translate over to solid and there may need to be some massaging. But again wondering if there are some technical limitations?
I've just completed a solidjs port of mantine's core and 105 components and 24 hooks (out of 73) and some of it was trivial, other parts were really difficult to nail the reactivity. 😮💨 Especially when there's no feedback available from solid.
So if there aren't any sort of technical limitations. I really need this library myself and would like to contribute the rest of the missing features for the solid implementation. I'd be happy to do it after I have completed the mantine port.
I would welcome to hear the current experience of the team member who is in charge of the solidjs implementation on their thoughts and any gotchas they experienced!
reacted with thumbs up emoji reacted with thumbs down emoji reacted with laugh emoji reacted with hooray emoji reacted with confused emoji reacted with heart emoji reacted with rocket emoji reacted with eyes emoji
Uh oh!
There was an error while loading. Please reload this page.
Uh oh!
There was an error while loading. Please reload this page.
Hello!
I have a general query regarding react vs solid implementations. I see there is quite a lot missing from the solidjs port (and well the other libs vs react).
Please don't take this as any form of criticism. I'm bringing this up as I am genuinely interested if there are any technical limitations on why the solidjs port is lagging so far behind React, as skin deep they are mostly the same (i.e essentially being javascript and useState, useEffect vs createSignal, createEffect) and it shouldn't be too difficult to keep them in sync. Although from experience, I know that some patterns for react don't translate over to solid and there may need to be some massaging. But again wondering if there are some technical limitations?
I've just completed a solidjs port of mantine's core and 105 components and 24 hooks (out of 73) and some of it was trivial, other parts were really difficult to nail the reactivity. 😮💨 Especially when there's no feedback available from solid.
So if there aren't any sort of technical limitations. I really need this library myself and would like to contribute the rest of the missing features for the solid implementation. I'd be happy to do it after I have completed the mantine port.
I would welcome to hear the current experience of the team member who is in charge of the solidjs implementation on their thoughts and any gotchas they experienced!
Thanks!
All reactions